G Willow Wilson, Komikus Muslim Amerika tentang al-Maidah 51

Beranda
Komunitas
News
Berita dan Politik
G Willow Wilson, Komikus Muslim Amerika tentang al-Maidah 51

Xtyb

09-04-2017 18:46

G Willow Wilson, Komikus Muslim Amerika tentang al-Maidah 51

Terkait polemik komikus ardian syaf , G willow Wilson komikus muslim amerika berkomentar mengenai interpretasi al-maidah 51 di tumblernya. terlampir linknya

http://gwillowwilson.com/post/159367...-actually-says

Quote:

Here is the problem: the Arabic word in that verse that is translated variously as leader, advisor, friend, intimate etc is أولياء (awliya’), the plural of ولي‎‎ (wali). And it means none of those things.

Awliya’ in this context means something very specific, and among Arabic speakers, that meaning has changed very little over the last 1400 years. A wali is a legal counselor or sometimes a legal guardian. Some examples: an unmarried girl must appoint a wali to act on her behalf during a marriage negotiation, according to Islamic law. Your lawyer is your wali in court. The executor of a will is the wali of the deceased. A parent is the wali of a child until that child reaches the age of majority. You get the gist.

buat yang ga ngerti bahasa inggris, intinya beliau mengatakan artinya Awliya itu adalah Wali, orang yang mewakili secara legal seperti pengacara atau orang tua

Quote:

The Quran never suggests you can’t be friends with non-Muslims. Which makes sense, because, you know, the Prophet had non-Muslim friends.

Nabi Muhammad saja punya banyak teman yang nonmuslim jadi tidak masalah berteman dengan non muslim

Quote:

While there are some hardline interpretations that hold this edict applies equally to all situations across time and space, Muslim history is swimming in Jewish and Christian (and sometimes Hindu) advisors elevated to positions of intimate counsel in various caliphates, so it’s clear that for much of Islamic history, this verse, much like the Pirate Code, was more of a guideline than an actual rule. (If you haven’t read about Moses ben Maimon, aka Maimonides–Jewish philosopher, Torah scholar and personal physician to Saladin himself–do.)

tafsiran ayat itu harus lihat konteks di mana saat itu Muslim sedang berperang dengan non muslim bukan berlaku universal.
Banyak Khilafah yang mengangkat orang nonmuslim jadi penasihat atau wali, sehingga surat ini lebih sebagai panduan daripada peraturan.

OK saatnya panasbung bakal ramein tret ini,waktu dan tempat dipersilahkan emoticon-Ultah

10.3K

Kutip

123

Balasan

Komentar yang asik ya

Urutan

Terbaru

Terlama

Komentar yang asik ya

Komunitas Pilihan