- Beranda
- Komunitas
- News
- Berita dan Politik
[Ekonomi] Indonesia: Republik Kasino [21+]


TS
bayoesunaryo
[Ekonomi] Indonesia: Republik Kasino [21+]
Inilah sebuah komen dari seorang pembaca tentang kondisi Indonesia saat ini di sebuah situs ekonomi berbahasa inggris. Entah benar entah kurang tepat, menurut gw pribadi komennya sangat layak buat dishare. So take a deep breath and happy reading! 
![[Ekonomi] Indonesia: Republik Kasino [21+]](https://dl.kaskus.id/brianworley.files.wordpress.com/2012/01/casino_wallpaper_16.jpg)
Indonesia became a Casino Republic years ago. You will see a lot from the following tale!
[ A Sorta Fairy Tale of Casino Republic ]
The hot money trap is a blackhole. Once you fall into the trap, you won't be able to escape! You simply don't have the chance to build the escape velocity.
How they fall into the trap in the first place? Well, it's a bit complex. It's not obvious to average economists. When you have booming economy, there are many foreigners who want to share profits with you. If you allow many of them to gamble their money into your economy, you are providing them "Casino Mundial" with open arms. Their bets will be paid off well and profit will be shipped out of your country for good. Their profits will become your current account deficits. In addition, your central bank will be awash with foreign exchange. Unable to manage, your central bank will waste the money. With extra foreign capital, economy is overheating. Politicians see tax revenues increasing and go on spending spree. Exuberant consumers love to buy more imported goods. People see share prices rising endlessly. They pour all their money into stock markets. They even borrow to buy shares even at bloated prices. Foreigners see their investment return is even better. Remember that their profit is your current account deficit. They say thank you very much. They praise your economy with all sorta sweet words. You feel infatuated!
Suddenly foreigners see your current account deficit and foreign debt level is unsustainably high. They leave your Casino Mundial in a hurry. When foreigners exit your market, voila, you don't have enough foreign exchange to refund them! Now you have foreign exchange crisis! Your currency will tank. Your stock markets will tumble. Many people will lose lots of money. Now you are bust! In panic mode, your central bank will squander lots of foreign exchanges to prevent plunging currency and help foreigners' exit. What happened to all those money? Well, you spent some to import goods. Some were squandered by your central bank. The rest was taken out as profits by foreigners!
To fill this foreign exchange shortfalls, your government will have to offer even-more lavish casinos to foreign speculators to lure more hot money to flow in. They will make bigger profits, which means your blackhole will get even bigger! Your government's main business is to sell your bluechip companies to foreign investors to earn foreign exchanges. Soon your bluechip companies will be wholly or mostly owned by foreigners. Your economy will be mostly foreign-owned! Your people will be hard-working for foreign investors.
Whenever there is an external disturbance, foreigners will pull out money in a hurry, causing new foreign exchange crisis. It's a vicious cycle! Your financial market is foreigner's Casino Mundial where they can come and stampede as herds of sheep. Your economy will swing violently as herds of foreigners stampede. Preventing foreigners' stampede is your government's top national security priority. If you scare foreign investors with unsavory comments, you will be indicted! Your government treats foreign investors as angels. Frightening angels is a felony sin punishable with prison! Your democratic right is not applicable to the sin of frightening foreign investors.
Welcome to Casino Reich of Your Country! Your government says "Our economic fundamental is very strong. Please invest on our financial markets!"
Leave your comment and you'll be appreciated

![[Ekonomi] Indonesia: Republik Kasino [21+]](https://dl.kaskus.id/brianworley.files.wordpress.com/2012/01/casino_wallpaper_16.jpg)
Spoiler for Enjoy:
Indonesia became a Casino Republic years ago. You will see a lot from the following tale!
[ A Sorta Fairy Tale of Casino Republic ]
The hot money trap is a blackhole. Once you fall into the trap, you won't be able to escape! You simply don't have the chance to build the escape velocity.
How they fall into the trap in the first place? Well, it's a bit complex. It's not obvious to average economists. When you have booming economy, there are many foreigners who want to share profits with you. If you allow many of them to gamble their money into your economy, you are providing them "Casino Mundial" with open arms. Their bets will be paid off well and profit will be shipped out of your country for good. Their profits will become your current account deficits. In addition, your central bank will be awash with foreign exchange. Unable to manage, your central bank will waste the money. With extra foreign capital, economy is overheating. Politicians see tax revenues increasing and go on spending spree. Exuberant consumers love to buy more imported goods. People see share prices rising endlessly. They pour all their money into stock markets. They even borrow to buy shares even at bloated prices. Foreigners see their investment return is even better. Remember that their profit is your current account deficit. They say thank you very much. They praise your economy with all sorta sweet words. You feel infatuated!
Suddenly foreigners see your current account deficit and foreign debt level is unsustainably high. They leave your Casino Mundial in a hurry. When foreigners exit your market, voila, you don't have enough foreign exchange to refund them! Now you have foreign exchange crisis! Your currency will tank. Your stock markets will tumble. Many people will lose lots of money. Now you are bust! In panic mode, your central bank will squander lots of foreign exchanges to prevent plunging currency and help foreigners' exit. What happened to all those money? Well, you spent some to import goods. Some were squandered by your central bank. The rest was taken out as profits by foreigners!
To fill this foreign exchange shortfalls, your government will have to offer even-more lavish casinos to foreign speculators to lure more hot money to flow in. They will make bigger profits, which means your blackhole will get even bigger! Your government's main business is to sell your bluechip companies to foreign investors to earn foreign exchanges. Soon your bluechip companies will be wholly or mostly owned by foreigners. Your economy will be mostly foreign-owned! Your people will be hard-working for foreign investors.
Whenever there is an external disturbance, foreigners will pull out money in a hurry, causing new foreign exchange crisis. It's a vicious cycle! Your financial market is foreigner's Casino Mundial where they can come and stampede as herds of sheep. Your economy will swing violently as herds of foreigners stampede. Preventing foreigners' stampede is your government's top national security priority. If you scare foreign investors with unsavory comments, you will be indicted! Your government treats foreign investors as angels. Frightening angels is a felony sin punishable with prison! Your democratic right is not applicable to the sin of frightening foreign investors.
Welcome to Casino Reich of Your Country! Your government says "Our economic fundamental is very strong. Please invest on our financial markets!"
Spoiler for Opini kaskuser:
Quote:
Original Posted By pamegat_ruh►I'm sure it's not that simple. But we could do with more prudent government spending as currently a large chunk of it goes to salaries and operational expenses as opposed to infrastructure or production efforts which will further stimulate the economy.
Not sure if I agree with you about debts. Our debt to GDP ratio looks fine to me.
Not sure if I agree with you about debts. Our debt to GDP ratio looks fine to me.

Quote:
Original Posted By ..:137ER::..Waduh ... Ini tritnya pake bahasa indiheee ... Kagak ngarti ... 
Intinya sih adalah ... Ekonomi kita rapuh Karena neraca kita itu defisit ... Hasil pendapatan ekspor banyak yg nyangkut di singapore ... Pemain pasar modal hampir mayoritas asing ... Import merajalela ... Kebijakan eknomi hanya berupa jangka pendek ... Birokrasi terlalu semrawut ... Infrastruktur kacau balau .... Dan mata uang kita IDR itu dianggap sebagai komoditas seperti USD .... Ya gak heran sih negara ini tiap 5thn kena goncangan mulu ...

Intinya sih adalah ... Ekonomi kita rapuh Karena neraca kita itu defisit ... Hasil pendapatan ekspor banyak yg nyangkut di singapore ... Pemain pasar modal hampir mayoritas asing ... Import merajalela ... Kebijakan eknomi hanya berupa jangka pendek ... Birokrasi terlalu semrawut ... Infrastruktur kacau balau .... Dan mata uang kita IDR itu dianggap sebagai komoditas seperti USD .... Ya gak heran sih negara ini tiap 5thn kena goncangan mulu ...

Quote:
Original Posted By humble.king►keuntungan kami adalah kerugian anda 
mau bener ekonomi kita ? embargo diri sendiri ,alias merih dululah, pemerintah kudu nguatin sektor - sektor pertanian , perkebunan , kelautan dan kehutanan alias kebutuhan primer seperti pangan harus di kuasai 100% tanpa harus impor dari luar dululah........masalahnya mau kaga ngeberesin ???

mau bener ekonomi kita ? embargo diri sendiri ,alias merih dululah, pemerintah kudu nguatin sektor - sektor pertanian , perkebunan , kelautan dan kehutanan alias kebutuhan primer seperti pangan harus di kuasai 100% tanpa harus impor dari luar dululah........masalahnya mau kaga ngeberesin ???

Quote:
Original Posted By PuncJayaWijaya►nais opinion gan... 
Orang Tua kita sejak dahulu kala sudah menasihati :
JANGAN LEBIH BESAR PASAK DARIPADA TIANG....!!!
Ekonomi kita selama ini selalu lebih besar pasaknya....
Untuk memperbesar tiang yg kekecilan tsb, diundang lah "hot money" dan ekploitasi SDA yg berlebihan...
Yg membuat lebih buruk lagi ?
Sudah tahu defisit BBM, masih mengandalkan kenderaan pribadi sebagai sarana transportasi di seluruh Indonesia...
Alangkah malang nya nasib mu Indonesia... dipimpin oleh orang2 yg tidak tahu apa yg terbaik bagi negara ini...

Orang Tua kita sejak dahulu kala sudah menasihati :
JANGAN LEBIH BESAR PASAK DARIPADA TIANG....!!!
Ekonomi kita selama ini selalu lebih besar pasaknya....
Untuk memperbesar tiang yg kekecilan tsb, diundang lah "hot money" dan ekploitasi SDA yg berlebihan...
Yg membuat lebih buruk lagi ?
Sudah tahu defisit BBM, masih mengandalkan kenderaan pribadi sebagai sarana transportasi di seluruh Indonesia...
Alangkah malang nya nasib mu Indonesia... dipimpin oleh orang2 yg tidak tahu apa yg terbaik bagi negara ini...

Quote:
Original Posted By maniaklemak►yah mau dibilang kasino sih bisa juga. tapi sebenernya sih kalo mau dicegah juga bisa.lihat deh, ada poin-poin penting di situ
1. hot money
2.imported goods
3.goverment and central bank
kalo menurut saya secara pribadi, poin nomer 2 dan 3 itu penting banget.soalnya mau segede apapun poin nomer 1, tapi kalo poin nomer 2 dan 3 baek, efenya tidak akan negatif.
tapi emang dasar mental udah konsumtif dan korup, jadinya ya poin nomer 2 dan 3 amburadul
oh iya, mungkin lebih tepat kalo dibilang kita ini sebagai kasino udah rugi bandar deh.gede banget pula ruginya.
1. hot money
2.imported goods
3.goverment and central bank
kalo menurut saya secara pribadi, poin nomer 2 dan 3 itu penting banget.soalnya mau segede apapun poin nomer 1, tapi kalo poin nomer 2 dan 3 baek, efenya tidak akan negatif.
tapi emang dasar mental udah konsumtif dan korup, jadinya ya poin nomer 2 dan 3 amburadul
oh iya, mungkin lebih tepat kalo dibilang kita ini sebagai kasino udah rugi bandar deh.gede banget pula ruginya.
Spoiler for Opini Intermezzo:
Quote:
Original Posted By mbia►kirain kasino temennya indro
Quote:
Original Posted By terunik►ini forum indonesia kok pake bhs linggis, ora ngerti ane om 

Quote:
Original Posted By rickyAspero►wii karepe piee...???
walah curhat nggo jowo wae iso rak gan???

maksudnya gimana gan baru males mikir nerjemahin....
walah curhat nggo jowo wae iso rak gan???

maksudnya gimana gan baru males mikir nerjemahin....
Spoiler for Opini spesial:
Quote:
Original Posted By adnnin►ini luar biasa bodoh sumpah
kalo biasa ada opini dijadiin sumber berita, itu aja udah bodoh
lah ini,
komentar guest di artikel yang berisi opini dijadiin sumber berita?
tolol bukan main

ini komentar dari user sikko6 di artikel the economist. bahkan bukan artikel aslinya yang dijadiin bahan berita sama TSnya. TSnya rada2 gila
ini perbandingan komentar2 lain dari user yang sama (sikko6)
Do not disturb vampires! Or vampires will come to your home to feast your blood.
PS: I will go out to buy garlic and chilli!
Wodow Suu Kyi!
She's not a virgin island!
Germans are too religious!
They elected Reverand Mother Angela Merkel and Christian party again.
Bloody religious Germans.
Sharia laws will be imposed for punishment.
very insightful

kalo biasa ada opini dijadiin sumber berita, itu aja udah bodoh
lah ini,
komentar guest di artikel yang berisi opini dijadiin sumber berita?
tolol bukan main

ini komentar dari user sikko6 di artikel the economist. bahkan bukan artikel aslinya yang dijadiin bahan berita sama TSnya. TSnya rada2 gila
ini perbandingan komentar2 lain dari user yang sama (sikko6)
Do not disturb vampires! Or vampires will come to your home to feast your blood.
PS: I will go out to buy garlic and chilli!
Wodow Suu Kyi!
She's not a virgin island!
Germans are too religious!
They elected Reverand Mother Angela Merkel and Christian party again.
Bloody religious Germans.
Sharia laws will be imposed for punishment.
very insightful

Leave your comment and you'll be appreciated

Spoiler for sumber:
[URL="http://www.economist.comS E N S O Reconomist-explains/2013/09/economist-explains-11#comments"]Opini[/URL]
Diubah oleh bayoesunaryo 24-09-2013 15:24
0
6.5K
Kutip
47
Balasan


Komentar yang asik ya
Urutan
Terbaru
Terlama


Komentar yang asik ya
Komunitas Pilihan