- Beranda
- Komunitas
- News
- Berita dan Politik
Anggota DPR membuat marah Gubernur BI
TS
xenocross
Anggota DPR membuat marah Gubernur BI
Lawmakers anger BI governor with ruckus, tardiness
sumber: http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2...dJLk0.facebook
The Jakarta Post, Jakarta | Headlines | Wed, November 28 2012, 10:11 AM
Long known as a soft-spoken technocrat who rarely loses his cool, Bank Indonesia (BI) Governor Darmin Nasution exploded in anger when dealing with legislators from House of Representatives’ Commission XI overseeing finance during a meeting on Tuesday.
The meeting, which began 50 minutes late in an almost empty room, ended up indulging a lawmaker from the Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P), Dolfie OFP, who demanded the central bank separate the operational and policy making budgets in the presentation as promised in a previous meeting.
Speaking ferociously, Dolfie requested Harry Azhar Azis, the committee’s chairman who led the meeting, not to allow Darmin to start his presentation before the central bank answered his demand.
The central bank’s presentation actually included the separation and the detailed list — as requested by the House — but Dolfie claimed he was unaware of this.
The ruckus continued for 20 minutes before Darmin took the microphone and decided to cease the commotion.
“Why don’t you give us a chance [to explain]?” Darmin told lawmakers in a high tone. “To attend this meeting, we were forced to cancel our board of governors’ meeting and move it to Friday — something out of the ordinary for us. Please respect this.”
The lawmakers, taken aback by Darmin’s reaction, were silenced. Some of them attempted to cool the intense atmosphere in the room by requesting, “be calm, Pak, be calm”.
The central bank governor retorted. “Just ask [me] the things needed to be asked, do not just point fingers,” Darmin said.
Besides the prolonged protest, the central bank governor was annoyed by the fact that the meeting had begun 50 minutes late and the room was filled with empty chairs.
When the meeting convened, only nine out of 49 registered lawmakers in Commission XI were in the room. In stark contrast, BI came to the meeting with a full team, with Darmin flanked by all four active deputy governors.
To his colleagues, the 63-year-old economist is known to be a firm individual who never gets angry.
The meeting discussed the allocation of state budget funds for BI in 2013. The central bank governor said that BI would need at least Rp 5.5 trillion to finance its operations next year, a 4.8 percent increase compared to this year’s budget.
When Darmin delivered his presentation, a lawmaker criticized him for “giving too many technical details”.
“The next time you deliver your presentation, please do not cram so many things in like this as they confuse us. Besides, we don’t understand this kind of subject — please deliver it at a level that is easier for the public to comprehend,” said Sadar Subagyo, a lawmaker from the Great Indonesia Movement Party (Gerindra).
Lawmakers also criticized Darmin for letting the rupiah depreciate, which they argued was a bad indicator for the nation’s economy.
This is not the first time that a top government official has been at odds with Indonesian legislators, whom former president Abdurahman Wahid once referred to as “a bunch of kindergarten kids”.
During his meeting with the same commission in September, Finance Minister Agus Martowardojo banged the table in frustration, accusing the lawmakers of beating around the bush during the discussion of the state budget’s macroeconomic assumptions. (sat)
Dikenal sebagai teknokrat yang jarang terbawa emosi, Gubernur Bank Indonesia Darmin Nasution meledak kemarahannya ketika bertemu dengan anggota DPR dari Komisi XI yang mengurusi keuangan, di hari Selasa
Pertemuan yang telat 50 menit itu, di ruangan yang hampir kosong, kemudian diwarnai protes dari anggota fraksi PDI-P Dolfie OFP, yang menuntut agar anggaran operasional dan anggaran pembuatan kebijakan dipisah seperti yang disepakati dalam pertemuan sebelumnya.
Dengan berapi-api, Dolfie meminta pada Harry Azhar Azis, ketua komisi, agar Darmin tidak memulai presentasi sebelum tuntutan dia pada Bank Sentral ini dipenuhi.
Setelah ribut selama 20 menit hanya untuk protes masalah itu, akhirnya Darmin mengambil Mic dan mengatakan dengan nada tinggi:
Kenapa anda tidak memberi kami kesempatan menjelaskan?
Untuk menghadiri pertemuan ini, kami terpaksa membatalkan pertemuan dewan gubernur dan menundanya sampai Jumat, sesuatu yang tidak biasa buat kami. Tolong Dihormati.
Para anggota DPR terdiam karena terkejut dengan reaksi Darmin. Beberapa dari mereka berusaha menenangkan dengan berkata "Tenang pak, tenang"
Darmin membalas "Tanyakan saja apa yang ingin ditanyakan, jangan hanya menuduh.
Ternyata presentasi Bank Indonesia sudah memisahkan anggaran operasional dan anggaran pembuatan kebijakan, sesuai permintaan DPR, tetapi Dolfie mengaku tidak sadar akan hal ini
Selain kesal karena protes yg panjang (dan salah) itu, Darmin juga kesal karena pertemuan telat 50 menit dan ruangan penuh dengan bangku kosong. Ketika pertemuan, hanya 9 kursi terisi dari 49 anggota Komisi XI. Sebaliknya, BI datang dengan FULL TEAM, Darmin didampingi 4 wakil gubernur.
Para koleganya mengenal Darmin sebagai sosok tegas yang tidak pernah marah.
Pertemuan ini membahas anggaran negara untuk BI tahun depan, dimana Gub BI mengatakan BI akan membutuhkan 5.5T tahun depan, meningkat 4.8% dari anggaran tahun ini.
Ketika Darmin memberi presentasi, anggota DPR Sadar Subagyo dari Gerindra mengkritisi karena dia "terlalu banyak memberi detil teknis"
"Lain kali kalau presentasi, tolong dong jangan banyak istilah teknis yg bikin kami bingung. Lagipula kami ini kan gak ngerti masalah beginian
- - jadi tolong disampaikan dengan cara yg mudah dimengerti orang kebanyakan"
DPR juga mengkritisi Darmin karena membiarkan rupiah terdepresiasi, karena kata mereka itu indikator bahwa ekonomi jelek
KOMEN:
1. Udah telat, gak datengnya banyak, arogan jg protes masalah yg ga ada sampe 20 menit
2. Dijelasin ekonomi gak nyambung. Padahal harusnya yg disini ahli atau ngerti (DPR RI Komisi XI: keuangan, perencanaan pembangunan nasional, perbankan, lembaga keuangan bukan bank)
mau jadi apa ekonomi negara ini yg ngurusnya mereka
3. Gak ngerti tapi sok tau soal rupiah. Kalau ekonomi jelek darisananya ya rupiah turun sendiri kok BI disalahin. Apa karena biaya kunker luar negeri bengkak?
sumber: http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2...dJLk0.facebook
The Jakarta Post, Jakarta | Headlines | Wed, November 28 2012, 10:11 AM
Long known as a soft-spoken technocrat who rarely loses his cool, Bank Indonesia (BI) Governor Darmin Nasution exploded in anger when dealing with legislators from House of Representatives’ Commission XI overseeing finance during a meeting on Tuesday.
The meeting, which began 50 minutes late in an almost empty room, ended up indulging a lawmaker from the Democratic Party of Struggle (PDI-P), Dolfie OFP, who demanded the central bank separate the operational and policy making budgets in the presentation as promised in a previous meeting.
Speaking ferociously, Dolfie requested Harry Azhar Azis, the committee’s chairman who led the meeting, not to allow Darmin to start his presentation before the central bank answered his demand.
The central bank’s presentation actually included the separation and the detailed list — as requested by the House — but Dolfie claimed he was unaware of this.
The ruckus continued for 20 minutes before Darmin took the microphone and decided to cease the commotion.
“Why don’t you give us a chance [to explain]?” Darmin told lawmakers in a high tone. “To attend this meeting, we were forced to cancel our board of governors’ meeting and move it to Friday — something out of the ordinary for us. Please respect this.”
The lawmakers, taken aback by Darmin’s reaction, were silenced. Some of them attempted to cool the intense atmosphere in the room by requesting, “be calm, Pak, be calm”.
The central bank governor retorted. “Just ask [me] the things needed to be asked, do not just point fingers,” Darmin said.
Besides the prolonged protest, the central bank governor was annoyed by the fact that the meeting had begun 50 minutes late and the room was filled with empty chairs.
When the meeting convened, only nine out of 49 registered lawmakers in Commission XI were in the room. In stark contrast, BI came to the meeting with a full team, with Darmin flanked by all four active deputy governors.
To his colleagues, the 63-year-old economist is known to be a firm individual who never gets angry.
The meeting discussed the allocation of state budget funds for BI in 2013. The central bank governor said that BI would need at least Rp 5.5 trillion to finance its operations next year, a 4.8 percent increase compared to this year’s budget.
When Darmin delivered his presentation, a lawmaker criticized him for “giving too many technical details”.
“The next time you deliver your presentation, please do not cram so many things in like this as they confuse us. Besides, we don’t understand this kind of subject — please deliver it at a level that is easier for the public to comprehend,” said Sadar Subagyo, a lawmaker from the Great Indonesia Movement Party (Gerindra).
Lawmakers also criticized Darmin for letting the rupiah depreciate, which they argued was a bad indicator for the nation’s economy.
This is not the first time that a top government official has been at odds with Indonesian legislators, whom former president Abdurahman Wahid once referred to as “a bunch of kindergarten kids”.
During his meeting with the same commission in September, Finance Minister Agus Martowardojo banged the table in frustration, accusing the lawmakers of beating around the bush during the discussion of the state budget’s macroeconomic assumptions. (sat)
Spoiler for terjemahan:
Dikenal sebagai teknokrat yang jarang terbawa emosi, Gubernur Bank Indonesia Darmin Nasution meledak kemarahannya ketika bertemu dengan anggota DPR dari Komisi XI yang mengurusi keuangan, di hari Selasa
Pertemuan yang telat 50 menit itu, di ruangan yang hampir kosong, kemudian diwarnai protes dari anggota fraksi PDI-P Dolfie OFP, yang menuntut agar anggaran operasional dan anggaran pembuatan kebijakan dipisah seperti yang disepakati dalam pertemuan sebelumnya.
Dengan berapi-api, Dolfie meminta pada Harry Azhar Azis, ketua komisi, agar Darmin tidak memulai presentasi sebelum tuntutan dia pada Bank Sentral ini dipenuhi.
Setelah ribut selama 20 menit hanya untuk protes masalah itu, akhirnya Darmin mengambil Mic dan mengatakan dengan nada tinggi:
Kenapa anda tidak memberi kami kesempatan menjelaskan?
Untuk menghadiri pertemuan ini, kami terpaksa membatalkan pertemuan dewan gubernur dan menundanya sampai Jumat, sesuatu yang tidak biasa buat kami. Tolong Dihormati.
Para anggota DPR terdiam karena terkejut dengan reaksi Darmin. Beberapa dari mereka berusaha menenangkan dengan berkata "Tenang pak, tenang"
Darmin membalas "Tanyakan saja apa yang ingin ditanyakan, jangan hanya menuduh.
Ternyata presentasi Bank Indonesia sudah memisahkan anggaran operasional dan anggaran pembuatan kebijakan, sesuai permintaan DPR, tetapi Dolfie mengaku tidak sadar akan hal ini
Selain kesal karena protes yg panjang (dan salah) itu, Darmin juga kesal karena pertemuan telat 50 menit dan ruangan penuh dengan bangku kosong. Ketika pertemuan, hanya 9 kursi terisi dari 49 anggota Komisi XI. Sebaliknya, BI datang dengan FULL TEAM, Darmin didampingi 4 wakil gubernur.
Para koleganya mengenal Darmin sebagai sosok tegas yang tidak pernah marah.
Pertemuan ini membahas anggaran negara untuk BI tahun depan, dimana Gub BI mengatakan BI akan membutuhkan 5.5T tahun depan, meningkat 4.8% dari anggaran tahun ini.
Ketika Darmin memberi presentasi, anggota DPR Sadar Subagyo dari Gerindra mengkritisi karena dia "terlalu banyak memberi detil teknis"
"Lain kali kalau presentasi, tolong dong jangan banyak istilah teknis yg bikin kami bingung. Lagipula kami ini kan gak ngerti masalah beginian
- - jadi tolong disampaikan dengan cara yg mudah dimengerti orang kebanyakan"
DPR juga mengkritisi Darmin karena membiarkan rupiah terdepresiasi, karena kata mereka itu indikator bahwa ekonomi jelek
KOMEN:
1. Udah telat, gak datengnya banyak, arogan jg protes masalah yg ga ada sampe 20 menit
2. Dijelasin ekonomi gak nyambung. Padahal harusnya yg disini ahli atau ngerti (DPR RI Komisi XI: keuangan, perencanaan pembangunan nasional, perbankan, lembaga keuangan bukan bank)
mau jadi apa ekonomi negara ini yg ngurusnya mereka3. Gak ngerti tapi sok tau soal rupiah. Kalau ekonomi jelek darisananya ya rupiah turun sendiri kok BI disalahin. Apa karena biaya kunker luar negeri bengkak?
0
6.2K
46
Guest
Tulis komentar menarik atau mention replykgpt untuk ngobrol seru
Urutan
Terbaru
Terlama
Guest
Tulis komentar menarik atau mention replykgpt untuk ngobrol seru
Komunitas Pilihan